Should You Remove Old Songs From Your Spotify Playlist?

Yes, for most Spotify playlists. Remove the tracks that have sat on the playlist longest, whatever their release date, and keep the playlist moving without changing what it is. A playlist people follow for new music has to change every week, and it has to stay recognizable while it does. Here's which tracks to cut, which to keep, and a rotation that does both.

What "old" means on a playlist

Two different things get called old, and only one of them matters.

Old on the playlist is a track that's been in your rotation for six months and that your regulars have heard two hundred times. That's the one to remove.

Old by release date is a track from 2014 that fits your playlist perfectly. Its age is irrelevant. A great ten-year-old track that most of your listeners have never heard is exactly what a discovery playlist is for.

Why rotation matters

Three things happen when a playlist stops moving:

• Your regulars get bored. They hear the same opening every session, and boredom shows up as people quietly listening less.
• The average quality slides. Tracks you added a year ago were chosen by a version of you with a lower bar, and some of them would fail your standards today.
• The playlist stops getting shared. Nobody recommends a playlist that's sounded the same since spring.

One in, one out

The simplest rule that works: add four tracks, retire four. The playlist stays the same size, the bar keeps rising, and the maintenance never piles up into a project.

Where to cut from:

• Anything you've skipped yourself more than once.
• Tracks that have been near the top for two months or more.
• The bottom of the list, where tracks go to be forgotten.
• Anything that no longer fits the one sentence that describes your playlist.

Keep four fifths core and one fifth experiment

Rotation is how a playlist stays fresh, and a clear definition is how it stays itself. Most of what goes in should sit comfortably inside your playlist's sentence: its genre, feeling, and listener. About one track in five can push at the edges, such as a nearby subgenre, a slightly different tempo, or an artist from an adjacent scene.

Put the tracks you're unsure about somewhere in positions 8 to 20, where people who are already listening will hear them and a new visitor won't hit them first. Two weeks later, be honest with yourself: if you've started skipping a track, your listeners started skipping it a while ago.

Rotate from the top as well as the bottom

The common mistake is adding new tracks at the bottom and removing from the bottom too, which leaves the top of the playlist frozen. Your regulars hear that frozen top every single session.

A rotation that works:

1. New tracks go into the first ten.
2. Tracks that have been near the top for two months move down into the middle.
3. Tracks in the bottom third that you'd no longer add get retired.
4. Everything good that leaves goes into a private archive playlist.

The playlist stays the same size, the same genre, and the same feeling, and a regular hears something new at the front every week. How to order songs in a Spotify playlist goes deeper on the positions.

Keep an archive playlist

Make a private playlist and move everything you retire into it. Nothing good is ever lost, the cut stops feeling permanent so you make it faster, and you have a pool to pull from when you want to bring something back.

The tracks worth keeping for good

A few anchors are useful: tracks that define the sound of your playlist and tell a new listener within thirty seconds what they've found. Two or three of those, kept near the top and moved around within it, do real work. Past a handful, they stop being anchors and become the reason the playlist feels stuck.

What removal costs the artist

A track coming off your playlist loses the listeners your playlist was sending, and for a small artist that can be a real share of their streams. Most artists expect rotation and plan for it. What they resent is a track pulled after a few days, so give anything you add a fair run of a month or two.

When to keep a playlist the same

A few playlists should stay put:

• Canon playlists. "Essential 90s shoegaze" is a reference list, and the point is that it's complete.
• Album or artist collections. There's nothing to rotate.
• Seasonal playlists. These rotate once a year.

For everything else, and certainly anything with "new" in the description, rotation is the job. How often should you update a Spotify playlist covers the weekly schedule.

Rotation needs something to rotate in

Cutting is the easy half. Curators keep tracks they've gone off because finding the replacement takes the hours, and four good tracks a week in one genre is genuinely hard to find.

The old way to fill the gap is a submission platform: a queue of tracks from every genre, reviewed for a few dollars each, with most of them never fitting your playlist. Artists pay for those reviews to have their tracks considered for your playlist, which Spotify's rules don't allow, so it puts your playlist at risk too. On Soundmango you only see campaign opportunities for tracks in the genres your playlist covers, with your earnings shown up front. You listen first, take on the campaigns you want, and get paid for each one. One campaign earns you more than an afternoon of per-review listening, and what goes on your playlist, and for how long, is always your call.

Frequently asked questions

Does removing tracks lose followers?

No. Followers follow the playlist itself, and removing tracks leaves them where they are. What loses followers is a playlist that stops sounding like the one they followed, so cut what's gone stale and keep your anchors.

How long should a track stay on a playlist?

One to three months for most discovery playlists. That's long enough to give the artist a real run and short enough that your regulars keep hearing new things.

How much of a playlist should change each week?

About 8 to 10% for a playlist of 40 – 60 tracks, which is three to five tracks. A regular notices the change, and the playlist still sounds like itself.

Should I remove tracks that are still popular?

Move them down before you remove them. A track people still play is doing a job, and it does nearly as good a job at position 30 as at position 3.

Can I change my playlist's genre over time?

Yes, slowly and openly. Move one subgenre at a time, update the description as you go, and expect to lose some of the original audience. A sudden switch reads as a different playlist wearing the same name.

Can I remove tracks in bulk?

Yes. In the Spotify desktop app, sort the playlist by date added, select a block of tracks, and remove them. Move them to your archive playlist first.

Rotate weekly, get paid monthly

A playlist that keeps moving needs a steady supply of tracks worth moving in. Soundmango brings you tracks that already fit your genre, and pays you every month for the campaigns you take on. Start curating on Soundmango.